- Get Your Sh*t Together
- Posts
- Why good choices feel impossible after you make them
Why good choices feel impossible after you make them
You're not bad at making decisions. You're bad at sticking with them when they get hard.
You Don't Choose Wrong Things. You Quit When Things Get Real.
You made the decision to get fit. Felt good, felt right, felt doable. Then week three hit and your body was sore, your schedule got crazy, and suddenly that "easy" choice became a daily battle.
You decided to start that business. Made sense on paper, had a solid plan, felt excited about the future. Then the first client complained, the money got tight, and the "simple" idea became overwhelming.

Here's what nobody tells you: your decisions aren't wrong. You just don't accept what they actually cost.
The Planning vs Reality Gap
Every decision feels manageable when you're making it. Your brain presents the highlight reel: the benefits, the end results, the success story.
What it doesn't show you is the middle part. The boring part. The hard part. The "why did I think this was a good idea?" part.
Research shows that people consistently underestimate the time, effort, and obstacles involved in achieving their goals by an average of 40%. You're not choosing wrong things. You're choosing things without understanding what you're actually signing up for.
Why Good Decisions Feel Impossible Later
Here's what happens: you make a choice based on your motivated, optimistic self. But you have to execute that choice with your tired, stressed, real-world self.
Planning brain: "I'll wake up at 5 AM to work out." Reality brain at 5 AM: "Absolutely not."
Planning brain: "I'll save $500 this month." Reality brain seeing a sale: "These shoes are practically free."
The gap between intention and execution isn't a character flaw. It's a design feature of how your brain works.
The Real Problem: Non-Acceptance
The issue isn't that you're making bad choices. It's that when your choices get difficult, you interpret difficulty as evidence that you chose wrong.
Wrong thinking: "This is hard, so I must have made a mistake." Right thinking: "This is hard, so I'm probably on the right track."
Everything worthwhile is hard in the middle. Relationships, careers, fitness goals, creative projects. The difficulty isn't a bug, it's a feature.
Why Persistence Beats Perfect Planning
Stanford studied people who achieved major life changes. The difference wasn't better decision-making. It was persistence through the messy middle.
The people who succeeded expected it to be hard. They planned for obstacles, not just outcomes. They understood that feeling like quitting was part of the process, not a reason to actually quit.
Success isn't about making perfect choices. It's about imperfectly following through on decent choices.
How to Close the Decision-Execution Gap
1. Plan for the Suck
Before making any major decision, ask: "What will make me want to quit in month two?" Then plan for those moments specifically.
Starting a business? Plan for the first angry customer, the cash flow problems, the self-doubt spiral.
2. Expect the Dip
Every worthwhile decision has a "dip"—that period where progress stalls, motivation disappears, and you question everything. This isn't failure. This is where most people quit and successful people push through.
3. Redefine Success
Success isn't "this feels easy." Success is "this feels hard and I'm doing it anyway."
Stop measuring your decisions by how smooth the process feels. Start measuring them by whether you're still moving forward when it gets rough.
4. Build Persistence Systems
Don't rely on motivation to carry you through. Build systems that work when you don't feel like it.
Accountability partners. Pre-committed consequences. Environmental design. Automatic habits.
5. Separate Process from Outcome
You can't control results. You can only control whether you show up consistently. Judge yourself on showing up, not on whether it's working yet.
The Persistence Payoff
Here's what happens when you push through the hard middle: you don't just achieve your goal. You build evidence that you can handle difficult things. Your confidence in your own follow-through grows.
People with their shit together aren't people who make easy choices. They're people who make hard choices and stick with them when they stop being fun.
They understand that the voice saying "this isn't working" often shows up right before things start working.
Your Persistence Challenge
Think of one decision you made that felt right initially but now feels hard or overwhelming.
Instead of questioning the decision, ask: "What support do I need to keep going?" Then get that support this week.
Could be an accountability partner, a simplified plan, professional help, or just acknowledging that feeling like quitting is normal.
Reply with what decision you're recommitting to and what support you're adding. The most honest responses get featured next week.
Next week: "Why your environment is controlling your behavior (and how to design it better)"
Get Your Shit Together
P.S. Forward this to someone who started strong but is struggling to continue. Sometimes we all need permission to find it hard and keep going anyway.